Foreign Prior Art Discovery for US Patent Invalidity Cases
Finding, proving and using non-US references in IPR, reexamination and litigation Key takeaways Under the America Invents Act, prior art for U.S. invalidity is not limited by geography: a foreign patent, a foreign publication, or a sale or public use anywhere in the world can qualify (35 U.S.C. 102(a)(1)).In an inter partes review (IPR), only […]
Emergency Patent Invalidity Search: 48-Hour Litigation Defense Protocol
A structured, hour-by-hour approach to finding and organizing prior art when a complaint, demand letter or injunction motion leaves almost no time Introduction Patent defendants rarely get to choose the timing. A complaint is served, a preliminary-injunction or TRO motion is filed, a customer demands indemnity, a settlement offer carries a short expiry, or an […]
Inter Partes Review Success Rates: The Impact of Invalidity Searches on IPR Outcomes
What the numbers say about IPR outcomes through 2026 and why the quality of the prior art search so often decides them 1. Introduction Inter partes review (IPR) is the U.S. Patent Trial and Appeal Board’s (PTAB) trial procedure for challenging the validity of a patent on prior-art grounds. Created by the America Invents Act […]
Invalidating AI Patents: Unique Challenges of Obviousness and Inventorship in 2026
How the 2025 USPTO guidance and an AI-equipped “skilled person” reshape patent challenges In brief: In 2026, challenging an AI patent means working with two doctrines that sit under unusual pressure. On inventorship, the USPTO’s November 2025 guidance withdrew the AI-specific framework and returned to ordinary conception principles, so challengers must prove who did not […]
Prior Art for Invalidity: How to Uncover Killer References Against Asserted Patents
A practical framework for searching, evaluating and proving prior art in litigation, inter partes review and reexamination 1. Introduction When a patent is asserted against your company, finding the right prior art is often the most powerful defensive move. A strong reference can end a case early, drive a favorable settlement, or support a petition […]
Defending Against Patent Trolls
Using Invalidity Searches as Your Shield 1. Introduction Patent assertion by non-practising entities (NPEs), often called patent trolls or patent assertion entities, is a persistent business risk. These entities typically acquire patents, rarely make or sell products and generate revenue by demanding licence fees and by suing operating companies for infringement. Because litigation is expensive, […]
When Should You Conduct a Patent Invalidity Search?
A Strategic Timeline Introduction An invalidity search is a targeted hunt for prior art that could render one or more claims of a patent unpatentable, most often under 35 U.S.C. §§ 102 (novelty) and 103 (obviousness). It differs from a patentability search, which asks whether a new invention can be patented and from a freedom-to-operate […]
Patent Invalidity vs. Freedom to Operate
What’s the Difference? Introduction “Is this patent invalid?” and “Can we launch without infringing?” sound like cousins andare frequently confused. They are, in fact, different legal questions, answered with different evidence, at different times, for different decision-makers. Mixing them up can lead to wasted spend, false confidence or unnecessary abandonment of a product. This article […]
Leveraging Unconventional Invalidity Searches to Defeat Patent Litigation Claims
Finding prior art beyond patents and journals and turning it into admissible, persuasive invalidity evidence 1. Introduction When a company is sued for patent infringement, the most powerful defensive lever is often invalidity. A patent that should never have issued cannot be infringed. Yet issued patents carry a statutory presumption of validity and in district […]
Why Patent Invalidity Searches Are Critical to Your IP Portfolio
Testing the strength of patents before they are tested for you Introduction A patent is not a guarantee of exclusivity. It is a presumption. Once granted, a U.S. patent is presumed valid under 35 U.S.C. § 282, but that presumption can be overcome by evidence the examiner never saw. A patent invalidity search, also called […]
