Locating, authenticating and using early GPS literature to challenge patent claims
1. Introduction
The Global Positioning System (GPS) began as a U.S. military program called NAVSTAR (Navigation System with Timing and Ranging) and was developed across the 1970s and 1980s, declared operational in the mid-1990s and opened to civilian use long before that. Because so much of the foundational technology was described in government specifications, conference papers, journals and textbooks decades ago, many later patents that claim “GPS-based” features were filed against a rich, well-documented background. For those challenging a navigation or positioning patent, that background is a deep source of prior art. For patent owners, it is a source of risk that should be understood early.
This article explains how to find and use early GPS literature, especially military NAVSTAR documents and academic works, to challenge patent claims. It covers the legal framework for prior art, the special problem of proving that a military or technical document was publicly accessible, the principal categories of evidence, practical search strategies and how to present the case in district court and at the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB).
2. Legal Framework in Brief
2.1 Anticipation and obviousness
- Anticipation (35 U.S.C. § 102): A claim is anticipated if a single prior art reference discloses each and every element, arranged as in the claim, either expressly or inherently. See, for example, Net MoneyIN, Inc. v. VeriSign, Inc., 545 F.3d 1359 (Fed. Cir. 2008), which emphasizes that the elements must be arranged as claimed.
- Obviousness (35 U.S.C. § 103): A claim is obvious if the differences between the claimed invention and the prior art would have been obvious to a person of ordinary skill at the relevant time. The analysis follows Graham v. John Deere Co. and the flexible approach of KSR International Co. v. Teleflex Inc., 550 U.S. 398 (2007), which recognizes that combining familiar elements by known methods to yield predictable results is likely obvious.
- Which version of § 102 applies: Patents with an effective filing date on or after March 16, 2013 fall under the America Invents Act (AIA), where prior art includes anything “patented, described in a printed publication, or in public use, on sale, or otherwise available to the public” before the effective filing date, subject to limited exceptions. Earlier patents are governed by the pre-AIA version, with different rules for dates of invention and foreign activity. For GPS patents, which frequently date from the 1990s and 2000s, pre-AIA law often applies.
2.2 Standard of proof
In district court, an issued patent is presumed valid and invalidity must be proved by clear and convincing evidence (Microsoft Corp. v. i4i Ltd. Partnership, 564 U.S. 91 (2011)). In inter partes review (IPR) at the PTAB, the petitioner must prove unpatentability by a preponderance of the evidence, which is a lower burden. IPR, however, is limited by statute (35 U.S.C. § 311(b)) to grounds based on patents and printed publications. Evidence such as public use or sale cannot be the basis of an IPR ground, although it can support the background and knowledge of a skilled person. That limit makes the printed-publication question central.
3. The Prior Art Landscape for GPS and Satellite Navigation
The following categories typically yield relevant art. Specific document titles, dates and versions should always be confirmed from the document itself and from an authenticating source.
| Category | Examples | Typical relevance |
| Government interface and system specifications | GPS Interface Control Documents (ICD-GPS-200 in its successive revisions, describing the signal structure and navigation message between the space segment and the user segment); other GPS Joint Program Office documents. | Signal structure (C/A and P codes, L1 and L2 carriers), navigation message format, ephemeris and almanac data, time scales, user receiver processing. |
| Federal radionavigation policy documents | The Federal Radionavigation Plan (DoD and DOT, issued periodically); Standard Positioning Service and Precise Positioning Service performance descriptions. | System capabilities, accuracy, availability, civil use policy, planned augmentation, dates of public description. |
| Technical journals and proceedings | NAVIGATION (the journal of the Institute of Navigation), including its collected volumes of GPS papers; ION conference proceedings (including ION GPS meetings); IEEE position, location and navigation symposium proceedings; IEEE Transactions on Aerospace and Electronic Systems; Proceedings of the IEEE. | Receiver architectures, acquisition and tracking loops, carrier-phase techniques, differential GPS, integrity monitoring, integration with inertial systems. |
| Textbooks and monographs | Works such as Global Positioning System: Theory and Applications (AIAA), GPS: Theory and Practice (Hofmann-Wellenhof and others) and Understanding GPS: Principles and Applications (Kaplan). | Evidence of the general knowledge of a person of ordinary skill and of established techniques. |
| Standards and industry specifications | RTCM Special Committee 104 differential GPS standards; NMEA 0183 interface standards; RTCA aviation GPS equipment standards. | Data formats, correction message types, receiver interfaces and certification requirements. |
| Predecessor and parallel navigation systems | TRANSIT, Timation, the Air Force 621B program, Loran-C, Omega and later GLONASS documents (including Russian interface documents). | Satellite Doppler positioning, time transfer, hyperbolic positioning and concepts later applied to GPS. |
| Government and technical reports | Reports available through the Defense Technical Information Center (DTIC) and the National Technical Information Service (NTIS); university and national laboratory reports; theses and dissertations. | Detailed technical solutions, experimental results and early demonstrations. |
| Prior patents and published applications | Earlier navigation, positioning, differential correction and assisted-GPS patents (U.S. and foreign). | Direct prior art; also a map of what was already claimed and by whom. |
| Commercial product documentation | Receiver manuals, data sheets, application notes, trade-magazine product announcements and catalogs. | Evidence of public availability of features. Also relevant to public-use and on-sale theories in district court. |
3.1 What kinds of claims are commonly vulnerable
- Claims whose novelty rests on using GPS in a new field (vehicles, mobile phones, logistics, fitness, agriculture) when the underlying GPS techniques were already documented. The inquiry is whether the application of GPS to the new setting would have been obvious.
- Claims on differential GPS, correction transmission and carrier-phase methods when early literature describes these approaches.
- Claims on assisted or aided acquisition, where earlier documents may disclose the transmission of ephemeris, almanac or timing data to reduce acquisition time.
- Claims on integration of GPS with dead-reckoning, inertial or map data, where a body of earlier integrated-navigation literature may exist.
- Claims reciting data formats or message structures that appear in public interface specifications or standards.
- Claims that recite generic “computing” elements in combination with long-known GPS functions.
4. The Critical Question: Was It a “Printed Publication”?
A reference counts as a printed publication only if it was publicly accessible before the critical date. The test is whether the reference was disseminated or otherwise made available in such a manner that persons interested and ordinarily skilled in the subject matter, exercising reasonable diligence, could locate it. Actual access is not required, but accessibility is. Key decisions include:
- In re Klopfenstein, 380 F.3d 1345 (Fed. Cir. 2004): a poster displayed at a conference for several days was held a printed publication, with the court weighing the length of display, expertise of the audience, expectations against copying and ease of copying.
- In re Cronyn, 890 F.2d 1158 (Fed. Cir. 1989): student theses that were shelved but not indexed in a way that would let a researcher locate them were found not publicly accessible.
- Cordis Corp. v. Boston Scientific Corp., 561 F.3d 1319 (Fed. Cir. 2009): a thesis in a library with a card catalog was held accessible even though it was not indexed by subject in the way a researcher might expect, reflecting that the facts of indexing and catalogue practice matter.
- Voter Verified, Inc. v. Premier Election Solutions, Inc., 698 F.3d 1374 (Fed. Cir. 2012): an online article’s accessibility was evaluated on its facts, including how a researcher could have found it.
- Blue Calypso, LLC v. Groupon, Inc., 815 F.3d 1331 (Fed. Cir. 2016): evidence of accessibility must be assessed by what interested artisans could locate; a document with limited circulation may not qualify without proof.
- Suffolk Technologies, LLC v. AOL Inc., 752 F.3d 1358 (Fed. Cir. 2014): accessibility must be shown by evidence rather than assumed from the existence of the document on the internet.
- Jazz Pharmaceuticals, Inc. v. Amneal Pharmaceuticals, LLC, 895 F.3d 1347 (Fed. Cir. 2018): on the use of reference sources and evidence of public availability of documents in a later-searchable form.
- Hulu, LLC v. Sound View Innovations, LLC, IPR2018-01039 (PTAB Dec. 20, 2019) (precedential): at institution, the petitioner must make a threshold showing that a reference qualifies as a printed publication and the burden of production then shifts as the case proceeds.
These cases show that the question is practical and evidence-driven. Examine the dissemination, the indexing, the audience and the timing and prove each with admissible evidence.
5. Military NAVSTAR Documents: Special Public-Accessibility Issues
Government and military documents raise an extra layer of difficulty because they may be subject to distribution limits. A document that exists in a government archive is not necessarily “public.” Consider the following issues.
5.1 Distribution statements and release
U.S. Department of Defense technical documents typically carry a distribution statement that indicates who may receive them. Documents approved for public release, which are usually marked as such, can be a printed publication from the date of release. Documents with restricted distribution (limited to U.S. Government agencies, to contractors, or to specific offices) are harder to treat as publicly accessible, because the audience that could obtain them is limited. A restricted document that was nonetheless widely circulated within the relevant technical community may still be considered accessible, but the proof is more difficult. Where possible, identify the date when a restricted document was later cleared, when a public version was issued, or when its content was republished in an open source.
5.2 Public versions and revision histories
Interface and system documents often exist in a series of revisions and public versions may differ from internal versions. The revision actually available to the public on a particular date is what matters. Collect the revision history, the date of each public release, the distribution lists and any notices of change. A claim chart should cite the exact revision and the exact page and paragraph, because later revisions may include features that the earlier ones lack.
5.3 DTIC, NTIS and library records
Records from the Defense Technical Information Center and the National Technical Information Service can show the accession date, the report number and the availability of a document to registered users or to the public. Check which classes of requesters could obtain the report and when. A DTIC accession date does not by itself prove public accessibility if only registered government contractors could order the report; the distribution statement and availability notice should be reviewed together.
5.4 Official government publications
Documents such as the Federal Radionavigation Plan were issued as public policy documents and distributed through government channels and many were available through the Government Publishing Office and depository libraries. Depository library records, catalog entries and Library of Congress records can be strong evidence of the date and breadth of availability.
5.5 Congressional and public hearings
Testimony, hearing exhibits and committee prints may include technical descriptions of the system that were public at the time. These can be useful supplemental evidence of what the public knew and when.
5.6 Foreign systems
For GLONASS and other foreign navigation systems, interface documents were issued by foreign ministries and agencies and presented at international conferences. Locate the earliest public English or other-language version and check translations for accuracy and date.
6. Academic Prior Art: Papers, Theses and Textbooks
6.1 Journals and conference proceedings
Peer-reviewed journals and established proceedings are normally strong prior art because of their broad distribution, indexing, library holdings and publication dates. Obtain the printed volume or an authentic digital copy, with the cover, copyright page, table of contents and the first page of the article. Verify the publication date from the issue, not just from the web page of a later republisher.
6.2 Conference papers
The date of a conference presentation is not always the date of publication. The question is when the proceedings or preprint were made available and to whom. Check whether the proceedings were distributed to attendees, offered for sale, deposited in libraries or indexed in databases. Conference date and proceedings publication may differ by months.
6.3 Theses and dissertations
Theses can contain highly detailed technical disclosures, but they raise accessibility questions, as the Cronyn and Cordis decisions illustrate. Collect the library catalog record, the cataloging date, the shelving date and, where possible, the date the thesis was made available in an index or database. A librarian declaration can establish the procedures and dates.
6.4 Textbooks and handbooks
Textbooks show what was well known and may disclose techniques directly. Establish the edition, the publication date and distribution (for example via the Library of Congress, copyright records, ISBN listings and publisher declarations). Editions differ, so cite the correct edition.
6.5 Online materials
Pre-2000 web materials and bulletin-board postings are harder to prove. Archive captures (such as the Internet Archive’s Wayback Machine) are commonly used, but they require authentication, typically through an affidavit from the archive and proof that the captured page is what it purports to be. Consider whether a researcher could actually have found the page at the time, for example through a search engine or links.
7. Authenticating and Dating Your Evidence
| Evidence type | What it proves | Practical notes |
| Document itself (cover, title page, copyright notice, date stamps) | Apparent date and origin. | Necessary but not sufficient. Must be authenticated and shown to be publicly accessible. |
| Librarian or archivist declaration | Cataloging date, shelving practice, indexing, availability to the public. | One of the strongest forms of proof for library-held documents. Include catalog screenshots and stamps. |
| Publisher or organization declaration | Date of distribution, circulation, subscription lists, sale of copies. | Useful for journals and proceedings. Ask for mailing records and sales data. |
| Author declaration | Date of presentation, distribution to attendees, copies given to colleagues. | Helpful for conference papers and reports. Be mindful of bias and memory limits. |
| Government records (DTIC accession, GPO, Federal Register, FOIA responses) | Official dates and distribution limits. | Submit FOIA requests early. Responses can take time. |
| Web archive records | Date a page was captured and its content. | Obtain a custodian affidavit. Check for incomplete capture and missing images. |
| Citations in other publications | Circumstantial proof that the document existed and was accessible by a date. | Supports, but does not replace, direct proof. |
| Expert testimony | What a skilled person would have understood and how the field located literature. | Experts with personal experience in the GPS community in the relevant years are especially persuasive. |
| Prior art database records (IEEE Xplore, ACM, library union catalogs) | Metadata, publication dates. | Check that the metadata corresponds to the original publication date and not a later digital release. |
Authentication under the rules of evidence requires evidence that the item is what the proponent claims. In litigation, parties often rely on declarations, business-records foundations and stipulations. At the PTAB, the petition must include enough support at filing to establish a reasonable likelihood of prevailing and later reply evidence is limited, so build the public-accessibility record from the start.
8. Search Strategy
- Define the critical date. Identify the effective filing date and any priority claims. Determine whether the AIA or pre-AIA law applies and the exceptions that might apply. The search should focus on material dated well before that date, with margin for proof problems.
- Map the claims to the technology. For each independent claim, list the technical elements and group them: GPS signal processing, time or position computation, data communication, user interface, integration with other sensors and application-specific features.
- Search the primary technical sources. Start with the journals and proceedings listed in Section 3, the major university libraries and the standards organizations. Search the full text of the earliest volumes and use the index and bibliography sections.
- Follow the citation chain. Review the references in the patent itself, in its file history and in related patents, then trace the references of the best papers. Use forward and backward citation searches.
- Use professional searchers. Prior art search firms and librarians experienced with legacy technical literature can locate printed volumes, microfilm and non-digitized material.
- Search government repositories. Search DTIC, NTIS, GPO and national archives. Submit FOIA requests where documents may exist but are not online.
- Interview former practitioners. Retired engineers, professors and program staff can identify documents, collections and conference proceedings that never reached the web.
- Search foreign-language sources where the claims relate to GLONASS, Galileo, BeiDou or regional augmentation systems.
- Preserve everything. For each candidate reference, preserve a complete copy with all identifying pages and record how and when you obtained it, from where and by whom.
9. Building the Invalidity Case
9.1 Claim construction first
Invalidity compares the properly construed claims to the prior art, so construction must come first. In district court, claims are construed in accordance with Phillips v. AWH Corp. (Fed. Cir. 2005) (en banc), by reference to the intrinsic record (claims, specification, prosecution history). IPR applies the same standard. Terms of art in navigation, such as “pseudorange,” “ephemeris,” “almanac,” “carrier-phase” and “integrity,” have established meanings; use the contemporaneous literature to show those meanings.
9.2 Claim charts
A claim chart maps each limitation to specific disclosures in the reference, with page, column, figure and paragraph citations. For obviousness, add a column explaining the motivation to combine, any reasonable expectation of success and why any differences would have been obvious. Where a single reference is not enough, explain which reference supplies each element and why a skilled person would have combined them, with citations to the references themselves, textbooks or expert evidence showing the state of the art.
9.3 Typical combinations
- Government specification plus academic paper: The specification supplies the signal and message structure; the paper supplies the receiver or algorithm.
- Academic paper plus textbook: The paper discloses a technique; the textbook shows the technique was routine and supplies missing details.
- Prior GPS patent plus standards document: The patent shows a method; the standard shows data formats used in the claims.
- Navigation reference plus general-purpose computing reference: For claims that add generic computer or networking steps to a known navigation function.
9.4 Anticipating inherent features
A reference may inherently disclose features not expressly stated if the missing feature is necessarily present. The Federal Circuit has said that inherency cannot be established by probabilities or possibilities. For GPS references, an expert may be able to show that a stated operation necessarily involves a particular computation or data element, for example that obtaining a position fix from four or more satellites necessarily requires solving for receiver clock bias.
9.5 Responding to common patent owner arguments
| Patent owner argument | Typical response |
| The reference was not publicly accessible. | Provide declarations, catalog records, distribution evidence and indexing proof. Show how a skilled researcher exercising diligence would have found it. |
| The reference does not disclose a limitation. | Show express or inherent disclosure, or identify a second reference that supplies the limitation and explain the motivation to combine. |
| Hindsight reconstruction. | Tie each combination to explicit teachings in the references or to demonstrable common knowledge of the field at the time. |
| Teaching away. | Show that the reference does not discourage the combination, or that the alternative was still a known option. |
| Secondary considerations (commercial success, long-felt need, copying, praise). | Challenge the nexus between the claimed features and the evidence and show the success is due to other factors such as the underlying GPS infrastructure. |
| The new use is a distinct technical problem. | Show that known solutions to the same or analogous problems were available and that applying GPS to a new device was a predictable use of a known technology. |
10. District Court and PTAB: Strategic Differences
| Issue | District court | PTAB (IPR) |
| Burden of proof | Clear and convincing evidence | Preponderance of the evidence |
| Prior art types | Patents, printed publications, public use, sale, other prior art categories | Patents and printed publications only (§ 311(b)) |
| Public accessibility | Proved at trial with live and documentary evidence; fact disputes for the jury | Must be shown early; threshold showing at institution and fuller proof during trial |
| Expert evidence | Live testimony | Declarations and cross-examination by deposition |
| Timing | Often several years | Institution decision in about six months from filing; final written decision within one year of institution |
| Estoppel | Not applicable to prior district court invalidity rulings in the same way | Estoppel can limit later arguments on grounds raised or reasonably could have been raised |
| Discretionary denial | Not applicable | The Board may decline institution based on parallel litigation timing and other factors under its current practice. Check the latest guidance. |
Because the rules and policies on institution change, confirm the current PTAB practice before choosing a forum. Ex parte reexamination is another option that also relies on patents and printed publications and offers a lower-cost route that can be filed anonymously.
11. Risks and Practical Cautions
- Overreliance on dates printed on documents. A date on the cover may be the date of writing, not the date of public release.
- Neglecting distribution limits. Failing to check whether a military document was restricted can lead to a failed ground.
- Confusing versions. Different revisions of an interface document or different editions of a book disclose different things.
- Late discovery of authentication problems. Third-party custodians can be slow to respond. Start requests early and use subpoenas in litigation where needed.
- Export-control or classification concerns. Verify that any document you use is lawfully obtainable and is not subject to access restrictions or handling rules and seek guidance from counsel before obtaining or using restricted government material.
- Expert qualifications. An expert who did not work in the field in the relevant period may have difficulty testifying about what a skilled person knew then.
- Prosecution history. Review what the examiner considered. References already considered face an uphill battle in some proceedings, although new context or evidence can still prevail.
- Claim amendments. In IPR and reexamination, the patent owner may amend. Anticipate narrower claims and gather art on likely amendments.
12. Guidance for Patent Owners and Applicants
The same knowledge helps the other side. If you are drafting or defending a navigation patent:
- Search the early GPS literature before filing and, where required, disclose material references to the Office under the duty of disclosure (37 C.F.R. § 1.56).
- Focus claims on what is really new: specific algorithms, architectures or data flows that go beyond the documented basics, rather than the general use of GPS in a new setting.
- Draft the specification with fallback positions, so that dependent claims recite more specific technical features that are harder to find in the older literature.
- Document development history, so that any date-of-invention or derivation question can be answered.
- When facing an invalidity challenge, scrutinize each reference’s public accessibility and date and be ready to demand proof.
13. Checklist for a GPS Invalidity Project
- Effective filing date, priority chain and applicable law (AIA or pre-AIA) identified.
- Claims construed, with navigation terms of art tied to contemporaneous sources.
- Technology elements grouped and searched across government, academic, standards and product sources.
- Every candidate reference preserved in full, with cover, date and publication information.
- Public accessibility evidence collected for each reference (catalogs, distribution statements, declarations, archive affidavits).
- Distribution restrictions and revision history reviewed for each military document.
- Claim charts prepared for each ground, with exact citations and motivation-to-combine analysis.
- Expert with relevant historical experience retained early.
- Forum selected (district court, IPR, reexamination) with awareness of the printed-publication limit in IPR.
- Response prepared for anticipated patent owner arguments on accessibility, combination and secondary considerations.
- Third-party records (libraries, publishers, government agencies) requested well ahead of deadlines.
14. Conclusion
GPS and satellite navigation are fields with a large, well-documented early literature: military NAVSTAR interface and system documents, government policy plans, specialized journals and proceedings, standards and textbooks. That literature can anticipate or render obvious many later patent claims. But strong prior art is only strong if it can be proven. The decisive questions are usually not what a document says but whether it was publicly accessible before the critical date, which revision was available and who could have found it. Build the accessibility record as carefully as the technical mapping, take special care with documents that carry distribution restrictions, tie every combination to the knowledge of a person of ordinary skill at the time and choose the forum with its evidentiary limits in mind.
